Monday, June 24, 2019

Editing labelling

When I begin editing, I start by taking clips from my sd card and putting them onto the computer in folders named for the project and unit they are for, such as Music Video clips, Promotional Video clips etc.


Then once I start editing in Premiere pro I create bins and move the clips from the desktop folders into those bins on premiere, where I drag them from and edit them into a video.


I also then divide the clips up in different bins to pick out the good clips and bad clips so i don't have to spend as much time going through all of them to find the ones I'm going to use in the final edit.

Friday, June 21, 2019

Music Video Gantt Chart


Music video Ideas planning

In this 17 minute audio clip, me, Jack and Morgan discuss ideas for our music video, going over what we would like to try and create, what messages we want to get across, and what audiences we are trying to target and how we will target those audiences through techniques and styles.

Tuesday, June 18, 2019

History of Editing

Editing

In the early days of film, editing was done in very different ways to how we edit films in the modern day. For example at the very start of film, to edit clips together the editor would just literally cut the film with a razor and then reorder and paste them in a new sequence to give the film some continuity, which is why this early form of editing was referred to as continuity editing.

The next significant improvement to editing film was in 1924 when the invention of the moviola came about, this machine allowed the editor to watch the editing being projected while they edit the footage making it easier to see what they are editing and when to best to make a cut in the footage. The Moviola was used primarily as the main editing machine in the US up until 1970, it was around here when Flatbed edit systems became a more common practice.

Flatbed Edit Suites were the next major editing system for editors after 1970. The flatbed editors allowed for picture and sound rolls to be loaded onto the machine and edited at the same time, this allowed for the pictures and audio to be synchronised, it worked the in almost the same way in allowing the editor to see what he's editing, just with the added ability to keep the audio and film synchronised.

After this editing techniques and technology started entering the modern age and moving onto powerful computers using software such as Premiere Pro, or final cut which allowed for much editing to be much simpler and affordable as well as reducing the amount of editors required

Research Techniques


Focus Groups

Focus groups are a research method that involves the gathering of multiple selected people, to participate in a discussion about a specific topic in which they are encouraged to give their opinions and discuss with others.

A focus group allows for the gathering of qualitative data over quantitative data that a questionnaire would provide. Thanks to it being a discussion in person it means that the people can give more in depth and personalised answers to the topic of discussion, where they can then interact with others giving arguments for and against points made. This allows the researcher to get a more thorough opinion that can then be used to help influence the outcome of the research by having a broader perspective.

Pros:
Quantitative over qualitative data.
Everyone has an opportunity to give their opinion
Can verify or clarify results from a survey



Questionnaires
Pros
They are cost efficient, the reason for this is how easily they can be made and distributed. They can be created from scratch on a document, or be made on a template from a website. Then they can be emailed, texted or mailed or even just handed out in person.

They also allow for comparability of answers, and easy analysis of the results, as well as providing quantitative data.

Cons
Can get dishonest answers
Can be hard to interpret answers correctly



Evaluation of practical skills

At the start of the year I began with a decent amount of knowledge on video production after doing several years of media and film studies where I had the ability to learn how to use cameras and also techniques of filming and skills when it comes to creating videos. Of course though I was still an amateur when it came to creating videos and so this leads onto the first production I made with the help of two friends which was called Life of fly.

Life of Fly was our first attempt at creating a video as part of the course, and for this particular video we had four hours to come up with an idea for an unusual perspective, and so I though that we could create a video from the perspective of a fly, and so to help create this view we decided to simply take out a camera and move it around in a random motion sort of like how you would see a fly move around in real life. Now due to this being one of our first videos and only being a simple idea, the practical skills put into it were fairly limited, other than getting the ISO and aperture right to make the video look nicer.

The next video that I was able to apply practical skills directly to would of been my music video in which I shot the majority of the footage for. Now the space between the first video where I was able to apply practical skills and the music video was rather large, but I was able to continue learning more skills through lessons and general practicing with cameras in my free time. But in the music video we had the plan to create a narrative video that told a story throughout the song, and so this meant I could use a variety of skills to help give across a narrative. For example I used a number of close up shots to show emotion on the characters faces, and also some medium two shots that could show the actions of the characters and their emotion together. I also used an establishing shot which required me to move the camera throughout the home panning it around to follow the movement of the room. I believe that these skills shown in the music video are a huge improvement than that shown in the previous video, and also from when I began the year only knowing the types of skills and rarely implementing them into any effect.



After this I did some more videos for a client at the college who needed some assistance filming some presentations, and so this allowed me to once again apply to practical skills even if in a minimal form. All I had to do for these was just set up a camera and frame it so that both the presenters and the screen would be in shot with the correct lighting to see the screen and also the people in it. We also chose to use a two camera set up for this to see if we could get any better way of presenting the presentations on video which did go well.

My next production was the promotional video in which I got to apply more practical skills simply through the use of panning shots to let the audience feel like they are gazing through the work place themselves and getting a good look, and the panning shots allowed for this by showing a lot of the workplace in one take. I also planned ahead for the idea to use panning shots to be able to use fades in editing to make the advert seem smoother and flow better as an advert should do. I also chose to include an establishing shot to obviously show the audience what is being advertised, as this made a lot of sense to do for an advert. Some other unique skills I had to apply were a static shot that was focused on a specific spot where a car would have to reverse into, in order to show off the company logo since I didn't have any graphic on hand to use in editing. And also I did a transition with the camera by getting a close up of a light turning on and causing the footage to go white.

Personally my practical skills I feel have definitely improved since beginning the course, and in my opinion my strength is implementing skills in videos to help create effect. However if I was to say where I was weak with my practical skills it would be with the variety of skills being used, for example it's all good using different shot types, but I could have used different lighting styles more, and other techniques that didn't involve the shot type, such as framing scenes in specific ways and using more techniques like pull focusing.

Tuesday, June 11, 2019

Evaluation of editing techniques

When I started the year I was quite an amateur at editing, I had barely ever edited videos or used any editing software, and as for the majority of the start of the year when we created any videos during the 4 hour film challenges, someone else mainly edited the footage as I didn't feel confident in my editing skills to do such a task. It was only about in November when I actually tried to edit and that was when I also learnt to do speed ramping, which I then implemented into a 4 hour editing challenge where we needed to edit a video using found footage to a song.

My first proper attempt at editing a full video was for my new wave film video which is where I felt I did alright editing the footage together, however it was still an amateur edit since I didn't edit to any beat or use any transitions.
Plus this video had the voice over created to the edit not the edit to fit the voiceover so it meant I didn't need to edit as much apart from cutting the clips up.

My second more improved attempt was when I created a music video in which I ended up creating the edit to the song, meaning that I had to cut to the beat to make it seem more fluid. Now there weren't many issues with this as I was confident in cutting to the beat but, some cuts weren't timed to the beat and some shots were quite long which could've affected the final version of the music video slightly. My overall choice for editing this one was to edit it so that it had a non-linear narrative, beginning at the end and using flashbacks every now and then throughout to show the mans memory. With this video I also used some speed ramping techniques I had previously learned in the year, and I used it to speed up a long clip of a fly through of the home and at the end to slow down the death.



Personally I feel this was a huge improvement of my editing skills as I was able to edit to the beat of a song successfully while also maintaining a non linear narrative, especially since my previous attempts at editing stuff was just cutting up some footage, slapping it together with no effects or transitions and then doing a voice over or track over the top of it.

My final piece of editing I did was for my promotional video which was a much simpler video to edit out of most of them I have done, and this is mostly because of how my skills developed over the year. What I did was a a slow paced edit for a short advert with some instrumental music in the background. To help keep a nice pace for the video, I added in some fading transitions that faded from one shot into the next which just made the video smoother and nicer to watch in my opinion. As well as that this video was also my first attempt at some new stuff in editing such as adding static text to the video which was very simple to do, and I did because I needed a way of communicating with the audience through the video. The other thing I learnt was how to blur parts of the footage in the video, which was necessary as to hide some private information that showed up in the shots, and after watching a tutorial on how to do it, I believe I implemented blurring very well and successfully.
 

Overall throughout the year my editing has definitely come a long way and improved hugely, especially my confidence in editing as prior to the beginning of the year I tried to avoid doing editing because I felt it was difficult and frustrating, which I still stand by after editing software has continuously set out to delete footage and screw up any projects I've been working on. But going from simply cutting and placing clips together, to editing clips to a beat and adding effects, I feel I've done well in my skills progressing over time.

Monday, June 10, 2019

Contact with Client

The client I picked was my father who owns his own mechanic business, after I told him about the work I need to do and he asked if I could make a video for him.

Majority of conversations I had with the client was verbal in person which not all was recorded, where majority of the discussions were about when I could film, what I could do.

I did manage to get a recording of one conversation with the final ideas of what my client wanted in which it's a quick 1 minute recording of us talking about what type of video he wanted me to make, and me suggesting some ideas that I could do, and getting approval for it

Equipment List

Equipment I used for the shoot was minimal

Canon 1300D DSLR camera
One tripod
Standard kit lens

Promotional Video + Evalutation


Overall I am quite pleased with my final video that I created as I feel that it has reflected what my client and what I also envisioned for the short advert that they wanted me to create. I feel for what I was attempting to make I picked the right choice of shots to make and also type of editing. For example, because the purpose is to try and show off the business and tell the audience what is on offer, I chose to use a number of establishing shots and panning shots as I felt that these helped best to convey the business environment. This was also useful as it means that for that potential audience who may be looking for a specific business with certain equipment, they can find that thanks to the use of panning shots that showed off the property. I also chose panning shots because it keeps the video in motion and not make it seem like its dragging, which is quite important for a short advert that is supposed to go onto social media such as Facebook, which is what the client had in mind. With the editing I went with a number of cross dissolve transitions as to once again make the video seem smooth and continuous and not to slow, also it slightly makes the video more interesting and appealing to view which is good for an advert because the audience might want to continue watching. I also chose to use text overlay to convey message as it isn't a lot to look at and read, and also on social media people may not be listening with audio and so text still helps get across the message. The song I chose to include over the top is a license free song created by my friend, and my choice of including this into the video is that if people are watching with audio is will just make it more appealing to watch with a nice catchy track over the top of the advert. Some issues I had with filming were the number plates of some cars that ended up in some shots, and so I had to blur them out, and another slight issue was with the lighting as the camera would sometimes pan from inside where the lighting is low key, to outside where the lighting is high key causing the footage to be darker sometimes or brighter, but luckily this didn't cause too much issues with the final footage.


Thursday, May 2, 2019

Production Video Planning

Location recce

Attleborough Fields Industrial Estate
RS Autos Electrical Service

   

Prior to shooting the footage I did recce of the location I was intending to shoot at and the images help show what I was working with.

When looking around I noticed that obviously working inside of a garage would mean I could face a number of issues that I would have to overcome, for example lighting would be one of them as the main source of high key lighting would be from natural light coming through the doors since the inside lights were quite dim, meaning that shooting would have to be done on a day with few clouds and a lot of light.

As well as shooting issues, where were also a number of health and safety concerns that I would have to deal with as I would be filming inside of an working garage with a number of hazards ranging from minor stuff to very serious stuff. Things include trip hazards from machinery and cables on the floor, to hazardous substances that could be spilled over. So when shooting I would have to take great care of my surroundings and where I will be moving as to avoid injury to myself or damage to any equipment I will have.

Health and Safety Issues:
Trip hazard from spillages, machinery or wires - Before shoot ensure surrounding area is clear of any hazards that could cause tripping
Falling objects from cars being lifted - Best way to avoid injury is with safety boots and possibly hard hat for extreme safety, just try to avoid standing under things that fall
Sharp objects, cuts and gashes - To avoid these it's best to try and avoid putting hands near anything that could potentially prove to cut skin, or if required where safety gloves.

Wednesday, May 1, 2019

Promotional Video Analysis


With this product marketing video from Apple we see many techniques used to promote the MacBook Air to its target audience. From the beginning, the video has a voice over narration from a senior product manager at Apple, so this gives the audience the impression that the narrator knows the product well and is telling the truth about the product and what it is capable of. The video also targets individual audiences throughout, by mentioning specific things about the product that apply to those audiences, for example for the more tech savvy audience the video goes into the specifications of the macbook such as when she mentions the 'Eighth generation dual core processor', techy people will be impressed and become more interested in the product because of its capability. It also targets people who might be into graphic design or photography by the mention of the screen and retina display, and also the applications that come with the product, and so that audience will be interested by the idea that they can improve their work with the features that are available. The video is also made to be very aesthetically pleasing by using a 3D model of the product and making the camera pan around it, and through it showing off every detail as the narrator explains every detail, and for those who just want a nice looking MacBook this shows that to the audience.

This is a short B&Q advert from 2018 that only lasts 30 seconds but gets across it's selling point and brand. It starts off with medium to long shots of homeowners looking miserable and disappointed and then cutting to a shot of what is causing the disappointment, this is then followed by a close up of an object shaped like an animal with them saying 'Do it' repeatedly cutting between all three different homes and people with the phrase repeating over and over again. This is to reinforce the brand of B&Q being the place for DIY and so it gets into the heads of the audience that they should solve their home issues themselves and to do that they should go to B&Q to get the materials. This is shown when after they stop saying do it, the camera jump cuts to shots of medium shots and close ups of B&Q workers holding items that they sell and that are very useful. This provides the audience with the idea that whatever they need ranging from paint to tools, the store will have it available for them on hand without needed to wait for ages to get it or someone to do it for them. Then we see shots of the people using the products, which can show how easy to use they are once again furthering the idea of DIY.

Friday, March 22, 2019

Final Music Video/Evaluation


This is my final music video for Unit 36, with the video being planned and created in a group with Morgan and Jack. The song was an original created by Jack which we then planned an original music video for, with each of us in the group creating a different edit based on our own ideas.


Evaluation
We started with an original song created by Jack, which we then as a group listened to and started generating some plans as to what type of video we could create based on the song. We all had similar ideas of creating a sad, slow narrative based video which we thought would fit the beat and pace of the song well. This obviously led to more indepth ideas of what we could actually film and we thought it would be easier if we could make a video of a couple arguing and then breaking up leading to a depression phase for the man. Jack then came up with the idea of relating the video to male abuse in relationships and trying to highlight the issues of male suicides which we then collectively decided to incorperate into the video and so this led to us planning a video about a man in a relationship get abused and then become depressed and eventually lead to taking his own life as to highlight the issues mentioned previously. We then thought it would be best if we each individually created our own edit with the footage we filmed together, creating videos based on the same overall plan but each turning out slightly different.

Firstly, when we began planning filming originally we had much larger visions, however these became unachievable due to a number of difficulties such as budgetary constraints, locations available to us, weather and time. We did manage to overcome these issues though in the end but, this did possibly cause us to have to shortcomings in our final product. With the Cinematography I am personally happy with our results from our days of filming. We spent one day filming all the footage we needed that required Jacks home, this day of filming went well as we didn't have to deal with any weather since we were indoors and also lighting was ok due to having the house lights. Of course though this wasn't all perfect, as the weather for that day was raining, the clouds limited the outside lighting meaning that even with the house lights some of our shots were still under exposed forcing us to compromise on footage quality by boosting the ISO in some shots to 800 at the highest we wanted it to go, to reduce the amount of noise, and also keeping the aperture as low as possible. In the end though even with some of the issues faced that day, I feel we did manage to get a decent amount of footage shot, and with a variety of camera angles and shot types to give us a wider choice in our final edit. For example we used a lot of close up shots and mid shots, as we felt these would allow us to convey the emotion felt by both the characters as this was a main focus for the video to be emotional and allow the audience to possibly relate to the video. A number of tracking and panning shots were used as well to fit the narrative idea, and make it feel as though we are actually following this man through his pain and emotion and life. When it came to equipment used to film the shots in the house we settled on using the standard camera and settings used to shoot film, and to assistance with some of the shots we used a powered gimble which helped stabilise a lot of ours shots, and this became very helpful with a number of the panning and tracking shots we used as it meant there was significantly less shaking with the camera giving us much smoother footage compared to doing the shots freehand. But, while the gimble was very useful it did have some drawbacks such as when using it to pan the camera it was quite slow adding a lot of length to the shot and preventing us from doing a lot more panning shots than we wanted. Since we were filming in a group too we also decided it would be best if we split filming and directing between all of us, with mainly me and Morgan switcing between camerman and director, with one of us filming a shot and trying our way of filming it and the other offering direction and assistance where needed, then obvisouly we would swap roles.

On our second day of filming we had chosen to shoot in some wooded area, and specifically one that featured a bridge in order for us to get a shot suggesting the suicide. This day of filming was a lot more difficult as we were outdoors in public, meaning we had weather to deal with and other people walking past and preventing us from filming at some points. The weather especially proved and issue for us on this day since it kept varying from rain, to wind and then sun, the sunlight would cause lensflaring on some shots, and the wind would cause our filming rigs barn doors flap about sometimes getting into the shot and ruining the footage which was the case with a few of our shots. The shots we got outdoors were I'd say pretty good since we needed to get a lot of tracking shots of the character, and also a combination of mid shots, establishing shots, and close ups. The tracking was to once again give a pace to the video and make it seem as though we are following him, the establishing shots were to obviosuly show us where he is and sort of hint to what he might do, the mid shots helped show his isolation and also his emotion on his face, and the close ups once again further showed his emotion. The equipment we used when we filmed the outdoor shots were the larger shoulder mounted camera rig, which gave us a lot of ease when it came to doing the tracking shots as it meant we could get more stability and control over our shots.

When it came to editing all the footage together, as a group we all realised an issue with making a video fitting the full length of the song at 5:24. I found this problem difficult to overcome as it resulted in my reusing footage throughout the video and even having to cut the song length down as to prevent me using the same clips ten times throughout the video. This obviously made us realise that we didn't get enough footage as previously thought and is something we need to consider next time we make a video of any kind. Another issue I came across due to lack of footage was trying to fill the length of the video without leaving clips on for their full length as it would slow the pace of the video and result in it looking more film like than music video like, so I ended up cutting up the footage and adding more cuts between clips and even cutting the same clip down just to fit the beat better and keep the pace up. My overall idea for my edit of the video was to have a non-linear narrative with flashbacks and flash forwards to give a story and give answers to the audience. Of course I had to give the audience answers for something so I started the video with an enigma of the characters death right at the beginning, meaning that the rest of the video then gave answers to that enigma and eventually ending with the same shot as it started.

In conclusion, I feel the music video was good, I am happy with the footage we got and with my final edit of the video itself as it achieved my expectations for myself as an editor and cameraman. However, there were some drawbacks that I need to consider next time when filming anything, and that's length of the video I want and also making sure I get enough footage to create the ideal video I want.

Music Video Research

Locations
Jacks Home
Jacks house is located in Coventry which for me would involve getting a bus or train to be able to go and film at that location. Some benefits of shooting at Jacks house is that it's private meaning we will be able to film without any disturbances, it features some open spaces and decent lighting for us to film in.

Galley Common
Has a bridge which will be very useful for our idea for our video, is outdoors however and can be very muddy, and slippery presenting risks of tripping or falling and injuring rocks, or even falling from the bridge itself

Devils Drop Bridge
Another outdoor location bit further than previous, featuring same benefits and also similar risks

Focus Groups
Me and Morgan both planned to do a focus group, and we discussed what we will do and what information we wanted. So we planned to show the group the song we were making a video for and we created a number of sheets which asked four questions so we could general idea of what the group would want so see for this song. These questions were:

Thoughts of the song
Colours
What their favourite genre is
What narrative comes to mind

From the 15 people in the focus group we got a variety of responses which helped influence our decisions for our music video. However, by only doing one small focus group we couldn't get a a good amount of quantitative data, and not the most qualitative data.

When going through my research I noticed many issues, for example the information I got from my focus group wasn't a lot, and this was probably due to doing a small focus group and also because of the lack of questions I asked and the simpleness of the questions which didn't get more detailed answers I was hoping for. If we had gotten a larger focus group we could have gotten more varieties of answers giving us a broader perspective of what our audience likes, which would have allowed us to create something more tailored towards those audiences. Also if the questions asked were also a bit more open ended we could have been given a lot more detail into what our audience might want and any specifics they want to see or what appeals to them. For example we could have asked what their favourite genre was and why they enjoyed it, which could have given us answers like having something more upbeat to watch and not too slow.

It probably would have also been good if I were to do a questionnaire as well as a focus group as this would have allowed me to get a much large sample size to work with finding out data of what genres are most preferred, and listened too meaning I could have gone a done something more appealing to a wider audience.


Jack who I worked with on the music video did also do a questionnaire however





Wednesday, February 13, 2019

Andrew Goodwin and Carol Vernallis

Andrews book Dancing in the Distraction Factory discusses that with music videos there are several features that apply to them.

Firstly is Lyrics and Visuals
With this he talks about how he believes that the lyrics of a song and the visuals in the video share a relationships, these come in three ways:
Illustrated, where the lyrics are literally shown clearly in some way, such as being actual lyrics written on screen or even being represented like someone crying if there is a lyric about crying in a video
Amplified is where the lyrics are exaggerated through the visuals such as showing physical effects or using metaphors to express the lyrics further
Last is contradicting where the visuals go against the lyrics and do the opposite

Second is Music and Visuals
This follows the same principal as before
Illustrated such as showing the music on screen with instruments or the band playing
Amplified Where the the music is given more metaphorical meaning
Contradicted where the visuals are opposite to what the music is like

The next thing that Goodwin goes on to talk about is that music videos also have genre, both the music and also the video, these are:

-Studio Performance
-Stadium Performance
-Location Performance
-Narrative
-Experimental

Then Goodwin also mentions Star Iconography, where the artist or star is heavily features in some way in the music video.

Voyeurism is another factor of music videos that Goodwin speaks about, and this means that the audience will see something they aren't used to. These could be things such as:

-Nudity, or revealing clothing
-Exhibition
-Frame within frame

Then there is intertextuality, where the video will reference other stuff in a homage way, or as a parody way such as:

-Other music videos
-Film/TV
-Books


Carol Vernallis in Kindest Cut (2001) had similar ideas to Goodwin however she found a relationship between the music video and the editing techniques used. These can be divided into 4 different categories:

-Narrative
-Editing
-Camera Movement and Framing
-Diegesis

Narrative
She says that most music videos are in-complete and that the rest is up to audience interpretation, making them think about the meaning of the video, she then goes on to say how some music videos choose narrative over performance and vice versa

Editing
With editing she talks about how "The rules of continuity editing are broken to draw attention to what is happening on screen" This means that music videos tend to have a lot of jump cuts in them that don't necessarily fit together but is done to keep the viewers attention. It's also done to match up editing with the beat of a song or lyrics.

Camera Movement and Framing
Vernallis states how close ups of the stars and establishing shots of locations are used a lot in music videos and sometimes the camera is moved in time with the beat or lyrics.

Diegesis
This is the narrative or plot, and there can be a lot of repitition of shots and frames that can be more apparant and more important than other shots


Friday, February 8, 2019

Vance Joy - Riptide Analysis


The video for Riptide is an interesting one to analyse because it combines several key features identified by Andrew Goodwin in his book Dancing in the Distraction Factory. I think the video Illustrates, and also amplifies the lyrics as the imagery used clearly relates to the lyrics, such as right at the start after the instrumental intro, the lyrics are "I was scared of dentists and the dark" and to fit with this the second shot is of a woman scared in a dentists chair, and then the third shot being a light going out into darkness, both of which are static close up shots to simply illustrate the lyrics and show the audience exactly what the lyrics mean. When the lyrics refer to all his friends turning green, it is followed by a close up shot of green dollar bills, illustrating the point that his friends are becoming green like the money, but it also amplifies the lyrics as it has connotations of greed, saying his friends only want money, or even that they are being filled by envy and jealousy.

Thursday, January 31, 2019

Sia Elastic Heart analysis


In the music video for Elastic Heart by Sia we are introduced to two people, an adult male and young girl trapped inside a giant bird cage. In my opinion I believe that this video mainly amplifies the lyrics, as there is no real show of illustration of the lyrics throughout, since there is no lip syncing or matching visuals to go a long with the lyrics. Therefore, it is purely down to the audience to interpret their own meaning from the video's connotations. For example the setting of the shot in the mise-en-scene being inside of a cage, can be representative of the someones state of mind, suggesting how they are trapped inside and have noway of escaping to free thought. It is also arguable that the man and girl represent a father and daughter, and how the father is abusive and represented like a monster, as he chases the girl around wildly and aggressively, but then also how he is caring and protective, such as how he carries her and dances with her expressing his love for her.

Wednesday, January 23, 2019

Unit 11 Bibliography



Aronofsky, D. (Writer), & Aronofsky, D. (Director). (2017). Mother [Motion Picture].

Chazelle, D. (Writer), & Chazelle, D. (Director). (2014). Whiplash [Motion Picture].

Furstenau, M. (2010). The Film Theory Reader. Milton Park, England: Routledge.

Hill, J. (2000). Film Studies Critical Approaches. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

Stevens, R. (1983). Freud and Psychoanalsysis. Milton Keynes, England: Open University Press.

Storey, J. (2001). Cultural Theory and Popular Culture. Essex, England: Pearson Education Limited.

Uhls, J. (Writer), & Fincher, D. (Director). (1999). Fight Club [Motion Picture].




Monday, January 21, 2019

Film Studies Essay Evaluation

Film Essay Evaluation

I centered my essay around the two theories, the theories of the id, ego and superego by Sigmund Freud, and the theories of mirror stage and Lack from Jacques Lacan. I chose those because I felt I could get a a decent mix of arguments for the theories from the films that I chose. I felt my choice of theories to talk about was good because they fit well together as Lacans theory goes into desire which fits in with the id from Freuds theory, so I think I made a good choice when considering the theories to discuss. The films I discussed to interpret the theories from were 'Fight Club', 'Mother' and 'Whiplash'. On this choice I also felt I made a good decision as Fight Club and Mother can both have Freuds theory applied to them but can be interpreted in many different ways allowing for good contrast that I could write about in my essay, and with Whiplash I felt it was a good choice to show the interpretation of Lacans theory because I felt that the narrative showed that off well enough for me to then write and discuss about.

When it came to actually analysing the films I think I did an okay job at it as I went in and generally discussed what I thought about the theory and how the film linked to it and how you could interpret from the film, then I went into some in depth analysis about my idea and showed certain scenes which helped prove my point further. However with Fight club I felt that I may have gone too into general discussion about the theory and how it can be interpreted, instead of balancing it with more in depth scene analysis to further prove my point and support what I claim. This I felt I also did with Mother but I did improve slightly as I gave more technical points after discussing my ideas about the theory and the film, but still below the usual standard of technical analysis. When analysing Whiplash I felt I did best out of the three films as I went into a lot of detail looking at the scenes to argue how you can interpret Lacans theory from it, but even on this one I probably didn't go into enough detail explaining Lacans theory and how it applies to the movie in question. Probably another thing I could improve on is incorporating my research and more quotes into my essay to help support my statements.

Overall I believe my essay was okay, I felt the topics I picked were good and I addressed them well with some research and technical analysis, but I could add more detail to those areas to further improve the final outcome of my essay.


Film Studies Essay


How can the theories of Lacan and Freud be interpreted in films through the use of cinematic techniques?

In almost all films created since they first were shown to the public, no matter what genre, you can find psychoanalytical theories be implemented, whether they be implemented by accident or through choice of the director. It is said that "film has stunned us by its seeming capacity to reproduce reality transparently." (Film Studies critical approaches 2000) and by being able to add these theories to film adds to the verisimilitude and heightens the realism. These theories can be found implemented in almost any film created, I however will be looking at three films in particular that fit the two theories I will study. The theories in question are Freud's theory of the Id, Ego, and SuperEgo or how I will continue to refer to it as the Freudism theory for simplicity. The other theory that I will look at in relation to the films will be Jacques Lacans theory of the mirror stage and 'Lack'. Now the films that I believe these two theories apply to will be; 'Whiplash' released 2014 directed by Damien Chazelle, 'Fight Club' released 1999 directed by David Fincher, and 'Mother' released 2017 directed by Darren Aronofsky.

Firstly we'll look at the representation of Freud's theory in the movie 'Fight Club', now I feel that This film represents the theory best purely because it's story and narrative is designed to fit the theory almost perfectly. To go into more detail the film centers around the protagonist who develops a personality disorder, and this other personality ends up fitting the id from Freuds theory exactly. The protagonists Id acts upon desires and doesn't care at all about consequences, which fits Freuds description, "The id is the source of all instinctual energy" (Freud and Psychoanalysis 1983) suggesting it acts upon instinct and desires or the human body. Throughout 'Fight Club' the character Tyler is the physical and mental representation of the id, and for example one specific scene that shows this well is when the 'Narrator' is breaking 4th wall and talking to the audience about what it is that Tyler does, he mentions that Tyler urinates in the mushroom soup at the restaurant before giving it to the rich snobs. in this scene the Narrator is in a mid shot centered in the camera with Tyler stood off to the side. With the Narrator talking to us we know that we are inside of his head and by Tyler being shoved off to the side it suggests the narrators state of mind as drifting off from focus moving side to side between superego and id  Now because we eventually know that all of this is inside of the Narrators we can begin to see that this was clearly one of his inner desire to be rebellious that the Narrator has, hating the upper class and wanting them to suffer in some way, but never actually acting upon it himself and instead letting his subconscious id do it for him. Now while the Narrators id shows can show his state of mind whenever the id acts rebellious, it can also be argued that other unique things in 'Fight Club' such as the house that features a prominent part in the movie, which you can debate to say that it represents the state of mind of the Narrator, and we can see this clearly in the mine-en-scene when we first see the house, as it is old and decaying, suggesting that the Narrators mind has broken down and slowly decayed to what we see with the house. It is inside of this house that we get the most interactions between the id, ego and superego, like in the scene when the 'Narrator' is scrubbing his shirt in the sink we see how he as the ego interacts with his id and superego, he even mentions how "Marla and Tyler are never in the same room" showing how his id and superego never interact together only with himself as the ego. We can then go on to see how Marla fits the archetype of the superego for the 'Narrator' as Freud describes it as "The superego becomes and important source of inner conflict as moral teaching and the demands made by parents in western society" (Freud and Psychoanalysis 1983) Marla in Fight Club is the inner conflict that the Narrator suffers from as he is constantly torn between her and Tyler, and due to the lack of a father figure for the narrator he doesn't get the guidance that Freud talks about with demands from western parents, so because of that lack of a father figure he is always made to choose his id, which is shown when he creates fight club, then project mayhem, and it isn't till he realises that he's become his id that he finally chooses Marla to help him. We see evidence of Marla being the superego when she tries to take control of the 'Narrator' in the scrubbing scene as she hugs him from behind with the medium shot, shows that she wants to control him, but the later close up on the cigarette in the suggestive position shows how even the superego is influenced by the id and can't resist desires and natural instinct.


We can apply Freuds theory to the movie 'Mother' too however it is less obvious and not easily noticeable in the story as it is with 'Fight Club', in fact it is fair to say that 'Mother' is a lot more liquid like when it comes to being interpreted by the audience as the The theory can be interpreted in many different ways. I like to think that the house itself can be interpreted as the ego, being the place where the subconscious id and superego live in. The superego can be interpreted as 'Mother' and the id being the guests and visitors that come to the house, and we can interpret this from the scene where they host the dinner party after Kane kills his brother. The house is where it all takes place as the camera is constantly panning around the house and showing the strain on the house, therefore we can assume that the house represents the mind as it's the ego, the character Mother is clearly the superego as she attempts to prevent people from ruining the house, we see through the tracking shots of her that she shouts and complains about the people who are sitting on the hardtop, as she knows the risk of sitting on it. The guests that sit on the counter are clearly the id as they act upon their desire, they want to sit so they do but they do't care about the consequences that the superego warns them about, then the inevitable happens, the mid shot with the camera centered on the counter, it shows the first sign of house beginning to decay from the id as the counter breaks off and the superego panicking about the irreparable damage. Now that is just one way of interpreting the theory in 'Mother', another way that could be argued for the interpretation of the Freud theory is that the individual levels of the house represent the id, ego and superego. The id being the basement of the house as we see it in the shots with low key lighting, and eerie diegetic sounds giving that tense and uneasy feeling of chaos being there. Then you have the ground floor being the ego, it is shown in low key lighting as well and high key lighting suggesting how it switches between the id and superego as they fight for control, and it is where the most damage to the house occurs. Then of course finally is the superego being represented as the upper floors of the house, for example when we see the wide long shot of the husbands office it's in high key lighting with medals and accomplishments on the walls, and it is where they consider to be safe among the chaos of the later acts. We can go further into this when we look at the scene when the guests break the crystal in the office, lighting becomes darker and the sound becomes tenser, as the husband locks off his office meaning now that only the id has control over the ego. This goes deeper as with the scene when Kane kills his brother the blood seeps through to basement, allowing the id to fully have access to the ego, we see from the long shot of mother standing under the light, that is the only source of brightness in the basement, it blows out suggesting that now there is no sign of the superego, just the id.

Now moving onto Lacans theory we're going to be looking at 'Whiplash' as I feel it allows for good interpretation of the Mirror Stage from the characters. Now 'Whiplash' doesn't directly mention the theory but the use of some techniques allow for the interpretation of the theory from the narrative. I think the scene where he goes through a practice montage almost trying to learn the song, is a good example of the mirror stage in 'Whiplash'. Firstly the fact that it is set out as a montage to show a passage of time as he spends most of his days and the hours in those days practicing one song in order to be perfect at it shows his desire to be the best drummer, and along with this montage we get the mix of diegetic and non-diegetic sound of the actual song being played, with it being diegetic when we see him physically practicing, and when he's not it's non-diegetic. This suggests that no matter what he's doing, his desire to play this song the best is stuck in his head, it's taken him over and it's all that he strives for, and "according to Lacan, we are born into a condition of 'lack', and subsequently spend the rest of our lives trying to overcome this condition." (Storey, 2001) To further support the idea that the main character is experiencing from this lack we can see in the next few shots with an  extreme close up on his hand where he has injured himself through relentless practicing, and then a reaction shot with a close up of his face, where we see how he is barely fazed by the fact he has injured himself and see it just as an annoyance preventing him from achieving his desire to fill that lack. Another good scene that shows how the idea of lack can take control is the car crash scene, we get quick jump cuts between everything he does showing us the rush he is in and how willing he is to try and fill his lack that we don't have time to see the specifics, and then there's the extreme close ups on the digital clock between them once again reinforcing the idea that he he is desperate to achieve his desire. We then get the actual crash, which is shot from a side profile of the character to show us what's coming and how unaware he has become of his surroundings. This once again plays into that idea of being so absorbed into his desire that he loses any sense of self preservation.

In conclusion, the theories of Freud and Lacan do not need to be deliberately included by the director, and can be interpreted in any way by the audience due to how they are shown through the use of cinematic techniques. In Fight Club we see Freuds theory shown through the use of character archetypes and how they fit the archetypes in Freuds theory. In Mother it is a lot more fluid about it's interpretation and can be applied to a lot of different things through devices such as the mise-en-scene, and audio. In Whiplash, Lacans theory can be interpreted also due to the mise-en-scene and audio. So therefore just by use of cinematic techniques we can interpret psychoanalytical theories from films, no matter how they are represented or interpreted.